Thanks so much guys! I can tell you put a lot of thought into this.
QUOTE (DeGroot @ Feb 24 2013, 12:30 AM)
Hey Gary,
Was there fret buzz before the set up? If so, maybe you should consider having the frets leveled if you are going to play it regularly. Having such sentimental history with the guitar it might be worth semi-retiring, if you are concerned about its safety. Nothing wrong with getting another guitar for daily playing and gigging.
Since you're already interested in getting a guitar that is different from your LP, like a hollow body, it might be worth exploring a new guitar and putting the repair on hold until your are more certain.
I really didn't notice the fret buzz before. When he did the set up, he took the bridge & stop tailpiece completely off to clean it. So I can only assume he set the action lower than I had it but not sure compared to where I had it set (& I did set it low myself originally but didn't do a good job setting the intonation).
QUOTE (mroberts70 @ Feb 24 2013, 02:03 AM)
Hey Gary, I had a whole other reply that I decided to change after giving it more thought.
Here is something for you to consider. I would get another opinion on your guitar and here's why...
First off, no offense to anyone but I wouldn't have full confidence in what a Guitar Center tech told you. Now, that doesn't mean I think all GC Luthiers are incompetent, but how do you know for a fact that his guy is legit?
Secondly, if you have only one fret lower, then which one is really the problem, that one fret or the 20 some other frets?
It may be that the sixth fret is truly the issue, and maybe that guy doesn't have the ability to repair a fret as it would more likely need pulled and replaced??? I'm no expert, but when I take my car to the shop for a a new tire, that doesn't mean give me 3 other flat tires to match the one offender. Maybe someone else here with more knowledge on the subject may see that what this guy is telling is the best, but for me I would find someone to fix the actual bad fret instead of putting a file to all 20 some other frets.
You may not have the best guy for the job if he can't even hear the buzz but you can. Again, I'm no expert...but I've only heard it being an issue pushing down on the strings too hard if its on a scalloped neck.... And that is just that you may change the pitch of the note when you do....not cause a fret buzz.
I just wanted to give you something to consider before giving anyone 80 bucks to file down all of your presumed good frets on a guitar that does have sentimental value. Those guys at Guitar center are there to make money, and I'd hate to see you walk away with worse issues with your guitar.
Take care Gary,
Mark
Great advice Mark! I would definitely go to another Doctor for a second opinion if it were my own health. I can't believe I didn't think of that. I think I was caught up in the emotion of the moment. Like I said, this guitar isn't just an instrument to me, so in my mind, I just wanted it "right".
QUOTE (sammetal92 @ Feb 24 2013, 06:06 AM)
+1 to Mark's opinion, I thought of exactly the same things as I read your post, Gary.
Thanks Sam.
QUOTE (DeGroot @ Feb 24 2013, 10:07 AM)
Good advice from mroberts.
Something else I was going to mention the first time. How is the action on your guitar? Raising the action in some cases will take care of the fret buzz. I have somewhat high action on my own LP or I'll have some fret buzz around 13the fret (Low E and A). Of course if you have to raise the action uncomfortably high, then I would just put it back to the original height. The good thing is LPs are easy to raise/ lower action.
Thanks DG. I didn't think to ask him that in the moment. I think this is a good recommendation to try.
QUOTE (Cosmin Lupu @ Feb 24 2013, 11:13 AM)
I agree with the advices from the guys and I would first try what DG suggested here! Secondly, if you try the hollowbody and you like it, take it
Thanks Cosmin. I'm not sure if he'll charge me to try raising the action on it but will certainly ask. I feel like I've put enough money in upkeep for the moment & if I'm to put any more out, I kind of like the idea of putting it towards investigating the hollowbody. I try not to make quick judgments when spending money although my quick decision above regarding making it "right" could argue that point.
QUOTE (GregH @ Feb 24 2013, 05:37 PM)
If I trusted the technician, and the low fret is not too low, then I would not be afraid to have the frets leveled. It’s a pretty standard procedure. If they have to remove a lot of material, then it really should have all the frets replaced. Replacing one fret (in my experience) is not too common. Most of the technicians that I have talked to don’t like to mix new frets with old.
However, raising the action will also get rid of the buzz. If you are not planning to use the guitar a lot any more, then raising the action is probably not too objectionable.
It bugs me to have equipment with known problems so I would probably go with fixing it but I don’t think there is a wrong answer here.
I agree. I do want it to be "right". It doesn't necessarily have to be right now. I am new to the term "fret dress" but I saw this comment, "... but requesting a setup on a guitar that has had no fret dress is a waste of time. It's just part of doing it right.-- Ron Kirn" (this comment is from another forum so I hope quoting it here does not violate any GMC policy).
QUOTE (jstcrsn @ Feb 24 2013, 07:02 PM)
look down the neck to see if it is straight, sometimes minor truss rod adjustments along with the bridge adjustments others talked about can find some middle ground without major work
Hey Cursin'. Yes, the tech did try adjusting the truss rod for me but that didn't satisfy me. The neck (as I remember; it is in the shop right now) did appear to be straight. He used a metal level that looked the size of a credit card & showed me how the fret was lower than adjacent frets.
You are at GuitarMasterClass.net
Don't miss today's
free lick. Plus all our lessons are packed with
free content!