Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Whats Your Favorite Metallica Album?
GMC Forum > Discussion Boards > CHILL OUT
Pages: 1, 2
Guitarman700
I would have to say master of puppets. its like they channeled the pure essence of metal into that album.
its so fast and heavy its amazing.
so post your fave 'tallica album. cool.gif
Gen
QUOTE (Guitarman700 @ Sep 23 2007, 10:10 PM) *
I would have to say master of puppets. its like they channeled the pure essence of metal into that album.
its so fast and heavy its amazing.
so post your fave 'tallica album. cool.gif

Master of puppets indeed!
The Uncreator
Ride The Lightning
Robin
Kill 'em all
symon
hard choice maybe garage days then killem all
much love and light symon
ZakkWylde
It's Master Of Puppets, followed by Ride The Lightning
VinceG
QUOTE (Robin @ Sep 24 2007, 01:44 AM) *
Kill 'em all


Deff. Pure thrash escence. They started loosing it as they launch more albums.
Fsgdjv
Ride the Lightning!
brandon
QUOTE (Fsgdjv @ Sep 23 2007, 09:56 PM) *
Ride the Lightning!


I'm going to have to agree with a lot of you and say "Master of Puppets".....everything before the black album was good though. But the real question is, what happened to Metallica? They used to be really good and the 90's rolled around and they just got really bad and they're just getting worse. The black album isn't terrible.....but I think that's the point they should have reallized it was time to call it quits. Same goes for Weezer, the Blue Album and Pinkerton were great....now we get songs like "Beverly Hills". I can never figure out how bands can be so good and then get so bad like that.
Guitarman700
QUOTE (brandon @ Sep 23 2007, 10:05 PM) *
I'm going to have to agree with a lot of you and say "Master of Puppets".....everything before the black album was good though. But the real question is, what happened to Metallica? They used to be really good and the 90's rolled around and they just got really bad and they're just getting worse. The black album isn't terrible.....but I think that's the point they should have reallized it was time to call it quits. Same goes for Weezer, the Blue Album and Pinkerton were great....now we get songs like "Beverly Hills". I can never figure out how bands can be so good and then get so bad like that.

Seriously, what happened to them?! huh.gif i used to love Metallica, then i listened to st. anger and i wanted to gouge out my ears with one of my Star Trek pencils blink.gif . granted, i always loved Megadeth and Iron Maiden more, but Metallica was a VERY close third. i wish they would get it together. come on guys! sad.gif
shredmandan
This has always been a very tuff question for me tongue.gif Choosing one album to be my favorite,but i would either go with Master of Puppets or Justice for all.Both of those albums i can still listen to all the way through
Guitarman700
Well it seems master of puppets is the perfect metallica album. everybody loves it!
Justice for all was great as well.
SLASH91
QUOTE (shredmandan @ Sep 23 2007, 09:36 PM) *
This has always been a very tuff question for me tongue.gif Choosing one album to be my favorite,but i would either go with Master of Puppets or Justice for all.Both of those albums i can still listen to all the way through


Same here.

What do you guys think- will their next album be thrash?
shredmandan
QUOTE (SLASH91 @ Sep 23 2007, 10:53 PM) *
Same here.

What do you guys think- will their next album be thrash?



I dont think so sad.gif You never know and i wont give up on them but i think there past that now and are constantly try to reinvent them self and stick with todays mainstreem music.I think you will get a st. anger style album again just improved with better drums,solo's again and hopefully a better voice.And if not that will be similer to what load was.Yeah they could prove me wrong and i hope they do .I would even be happy if they just made a album that sound's good even if its not hard thrash like th past.We will see as its supposed to be out at the beginning of the year
Robin
QUOTE (SLASH91 @ Sep 24 2007, 02:53 AM) *
What do you guys think- will their next album be thrash?

No. Even if they play thrash, it still need to sound thrash to be thrash imo. And that will probably never happen with that band.
DeepRoots
I'm a master of puppets addict myself. I hope next months album isnt as bad as st anger was (it is next month right????)
SLASH91
QUOTE (shredmandan @ Sep 23 2007, 10:06 PM) *
I dont think so sad.gif You never know and i wont give up on them but i think there past that now and are constantly try to reinvent them self and stick with todays mainstreem music.I think you will get a st. anger style album again just improved with better drums,solo's again and hopefully a better voice.And if not that will be similer to what load was.Yeah they could prove me wrong and i hope they do .I would even be happy if they just made a album that sound's good even if its not hard thrash like th past.We will see as its supposed to be out at the beginning of the year


I hope that your wrong tongue.gif ...I have a feeling you wont be though sad.gif
VinceG
there never gonna be able to pull off a thrash sound. Exodus and Kreator can barely sound thrash in there newer release, let alone metallica who lost there thrash edge after Kill em All. I could honestly say that if your a young band like Gama Bomb or Violator, thrash would be more aggressive but if your old your not gonna be able to put that thrash element into your music as much as younger generation of thrash metalers. Plus most of them are beer drinkers. Beer and thrash has always been a great combination.
SLASH91
QUOTE (VinceG @ Sep 23 2007, 10:15 PM) *
there never gonna be able to pull off a thrash sound. Exodus and Kreator can barely sound thrash in there newer release, let alone metallica who lost there thrash edge after Kill em All. I could honestly say that if your a young band like Gama Bomb or Violator, thrash would be more aggressive but if your old your not gonna be able to put that thrash element into your music as much as younger generation of thrash metalers. Plus most of them are beer drinkers. Beer and thrash has always been a great combination.


You dont think that Ride the Lightning was thrash?
botoxfox
Mine would probably be Ride the Lightning, altough I've never really liked Metallica that much.
FretDancer69
Ride The Lightning

cool.gif
kevin-riff-after-riff
master of the puppets, or the black one ...... cant choose
Juan M. Valero
The master of puppets, for sure wink.gif

the early albums sounds a bit bad, but they are good enough
Robin
QUOTE (Juan M. Valero @ Sep 24 2007, 04:07 AM) *
the early albums sounds a bit bad, but they are good enough

Hmm, I see it the opposite way tongue.gif Metal cant sound like Britney Spears
Ayen
Saint Anger!


Kidding tongue.gif



Ride the lightning, all the way.
FretDancer69
QUOTE (Ayen @ Sep 23 2007, 10:41 PM) *
Ride the lightning, all the way.


wink.gif Amen
VinceG
Ride the Lightning and Master Of The Puppets are still thrash in vein, there just not as thrashy as other counterparts in the scene. Like I said, they started loosing the thrash edge after kill em all, I didnt specifically said that there not thrash anymore.
Kai Muehlenbruch
Ride the Lightning + ...and justice for all cool.gif
mattacuk
I know little about Heavy Metal, but i did listen to Metallica alot back in school. And Justic for all was my fave, very good!
Ben N
i loved them all.. but for me its "and justis for all"
no question about that!! smile.gif
brandon
QUOTE (Guitarman700 @ Sep 23 2007, 10:23 PM) *
Seriously, what happened to them?! huh.gif i used to love Metallica, then i listened to st. anger and i wanted to gouge out my ears with one of my Star Trek pencils blink.gif . granted, i always loved Megadeth and Iron Maiden more, but Metallica was a VERY close third. i wish they would get it together. come on guys! sad.gif



what i do is pretend that after they put out the black album they decided that they just weren't cutting it anymore and decided to call it quits and broke up for good. it makes it easier to listen to good albums and not think about how terrible they are now.
Guitarman700
QUOTE (brandon @ Sep 29 2007, 10:19 PM) *
what i do is pretend that after they put out the black album they decided that they just weren't cutting it anymore and decided to call it quits and broke up for good. it makes it easier to listen to good albums and not think about how terrible they are now.

Good advice, ill try that. biggrin.gif
rokchik
...And Justice for All

hands down my fave smile.gif
Resurrection
...and Justice for All

Master of Puppets is a very close second.
Animosity
Master of Puppets

QUOTE (Guitarman700 @ Sep 23 2007, 09:23 PM) *
Seriously, what happened to them?! huh.gif i used to love Metallica, then i listened to st. anger and i wanted to gouge out my ears with one of my Star Trek pencils blink.gif .



Hetfield stopped drinking tongue.gif
Understudy
Kill em All and then both garage albums
Bondy
Master Of puppets defo
ActiveX
For me it's definitely Ride the Lightning
shredmandan
QUOTE (Ben N @ Sep 29 2007, 07:35 PM) *
i loved them all.. but for me its "and justis for all"
no question about that!! smile.gif


I wanted to say Justice as well cause i fell its there most intense riff's,but the lack of bass on the album is the only thing that holds me back from saying its not my favorite.If only they wouldnt have tryed to cut Newsted's bass out it would be a 100% Pefect album. wink.gif
VinceG
QUOTE (shredmandan @ Oct 8 2007, 05:46 PM) *
I wanted to say Justice as well cause i fell its there most intense riff's,but the lack of bass on the album is the only thing that holds me back from saying its not my favorite.If only they wouldnt have tryed to cut Newsted's bass out it would be a 100% Pefect album. wink.gif


They actually remastered that album along with other earlier once.
Juan M. Valero
Did somebody said "Saint Anger" ?? hehehehee
Outlaw2112
Kill em all... biggrin.gif
USAMAN
MASTER.....MASTER....MASTER OF PUPPETS.............
SLASH91
Still can't decide between Master of Puppets and ...And Justice for all cool.gif
Gus
My preferred is the black album (though And Justice for all would be almost a tie if I had to give notes)

P.S. Seems I am the only one to prefer this phase(black+justice) instead of the more thrash metal 3 first albums? Well, before being flamed I do like them, but the question is about the preferred tongue.gif
SLASH91
QUOTE (Gus @ Jan 21 2008, 05:46 PM) *
My preferred is the black album (though And Justice for all would be almost a tie if I had to give notes)

P.S. Seems I am the only one to prefer this phase(black+justice) instead of the more thrash metal 3 first albums? Well, before being flamed I do like them, but the question is about the preferred tongue.gif


Don't worry about being flamed here, man. It HARDLY ever happens, and is always quickly put to an end. Speak your oppinion without fear wink.gif
Stevie-Ray-Vaughn
Going to have to say MASTER OF PUPPETTS!!!
Gus
QUOTE (SLASH91 @ Jan 22 2008, 12:57 AM) *
Don't worry about being flamed here, man. It HARDLY ever happens, and is always quickly put to an end. Speak your oppinion without fear wink.gif


Hey. That was actually my first impression.The discussion level in the forum seems to be 1000% more polite and less biased than 99.9% internet forums smile.gif
Nick334
Master of Puppets. Black album in a close second. Luckily it seems, I haven't heard anything after Black album.
SEANCD2005
It realy depends what kind of mood im in I realy like them all but i think i tend to listen to justice or puppets a bit more than the others, well actualy i listen to there live stuff more
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2014 Invision Power Services, Inc.