QUOTE (fkalich @ Nov 14 2007, 12:27 AM)
My brother once told me something. You can try to get to people by trying to convince them on the morality of some behavior. You might get to them. However, nobody likes a baseball bat smashing into their knee cap. You can be sure that will be an effective determent. When people are afraid to steal this stuff, when they think they will get into trouble, they will mostly stop doing it. Up to then, only those who hold higher ethics on such things will refrain. Others will do it, and besides, this is just party of the glorious revolution against the evil capitalists.
In all of human history, I have never seen a single example of that ever working on a large, nationwide scale. Ever. It's a short term solution that's bound to fail miserably. And who's slamming capitalists? I've already stated that corporations have done more good for the world than anyone and anything in all of human history. I haven't heard a single person claim to be anti-business so far in this discussion.
QUOTE (tonymiro @ Nov 14 2007, 03:35 PM)
Cheers,
Tony
Thanks for the reply. Sorry that I misunderstood your title in the original post. I re-read my old post and I see how I came across as saying "if we can't afford it, steal it". While my argument leads to that idea, my main claim is that no band, artist, or record label can ever really "own" the music they make. Once they create it, it belongs to the world.
Regardless of copyright laws.
I think a lot of people feel this way, and that's what fuels "pirated" music downloads. None of us feel morally wrong doing this. The people sued by the RIAA are an excellent sample group. When you have a range of people from ages 12 to 70, who have never made contact with each other, live in separate parts of the country, and have no predominant history of crime, and ALL of them are guilty of music downloading, that tells me average people don't think of it as being "wrong".
I'm advocating that if you want a piece of music, get it. It's yours. It's as much a piece of your life as it is of the band that made it. Get the song however you want to. If you've got the cash, buy a CD, if you don't, download it. Personally, I use Rhapsody because of the quick downloads and song quality.
You shouldn't have to pay millions of dollars to look a .jpg of a famous painting, and you shouldn't have to pay to listen to the music that's a part of your life.
The business model will have to change. I believe P2P websites will eventually charge a subscription fee that will help pay for the licensing of software and music. We're at a turning point in technology. Just like with the invention of the assembly line, P2P makes products more readily available and affordable. And just like with the assembly line, businesses are going to have to adapt to the changing times or die off because they can't compete.
It may not be the "Power to the People!" revolution some people are talking about, but a technological revolution can influence the world far greater than a social revolution.
File sharing isn't bad, it's probably the greatest computer technology since the invention of the Internet itself. The problem is that the technology is so new people aren't sure how to properly implement it yet. What do you think the world would look like today if if electricity were banned after the first person died from it? What about cars being banned after the first DUI?P2P sites are in their early growing stages, but I suspect they will outlive us all.
---------
QUOTE
Minor point - allowing others to copy work in my University - and indeed other Universities that I know well - is an act of 'collusion'. In my University collusion would result in a hearing in front of the University Senate with penalties that range up to, and include, instant dismissal from the program affected and any other being undertaken at said time.
And tonymiro, I'm usually a nice guy so I'm going to assume you wrote that with the friendly intention of keeping me out of trouble. If that was the case, thank you.
You are at GuitarMasterClass.net
Don't miss today's
free lick. Plus all our lessons are packed with
free content!