Printable Version of Topic
GMC Forum _ PRACTICE ROOM _ Announcement: Rec Grading Tweaks
Posted by: Kristofer Dahl Mar 21 2013, 08:40 AM
Dear GMC http://www.guitarmasterclass.net/guitar_forum/index.php?showtopic=40697,
From time to time we need to adjust our grading criterias - and we have now reached this point.
We have had a staff discussion, and have identified a need for stricter/more honest REC grading. In plain English - we think we have let some REC takes pass that should have failed.
So the coming time instructors will change their grading a bit. This might mean more student tears in the short perspective - however we believe it will also result more successful GMC rock stars in the long run! Hopefully you can understand where we think priority lies.
I also want to point out that the staff team has agreed that detailed and honest instructor feedback now is more important than ever.
If you haven't yet submitted your first REC take - I suggest you do it http://www.guitarmasterclass.net/guitar_forum/index.php?showtopic=40697. It can take your playing to new heights unexpectedly fast!
Posted by: HungryForHeaven Mar 21 2013, 08:51 AM
I welcome this change.
Posted by: Cosmin Lupu Mar 21 2013, 08:55 AM
Kris is right and I will add that takes won't receive passing grades if guitars are out of tuning or bends won't reach the correct pitches Most of you guys are doing a great job, but you need to become more focused on the details that make the difference between 'ok'ish' and 'hell yes!'
See you in the REC Zone, gringos!
Cosmin
Posted by: Gitarrero Mar 21 2013, 09:27 AM
I totally second this, great idea and we will benefit from it.
I didn't submit a take in a while now, but for some of my last ones I wasn't really happy with the takes and was suprised to get pretty good grades.
I know it's hard to receive a bad grade, and I always think "doesn't Cosmin (or Todd, Ben, Gabriel etc) love me anymore?" but I think it's for the best.
Keep these useful changes coming!
Posted by: Gabriel Leopardi Mar 21 2013, 12:27 PM
I'm not that nice guy any more...
Posted by: Qenzoz Mar 21 2013, 12:35 PM
I like the idea of this! Maybe I'll try and join in on the REC system, I just have a hard time finding a lesson and then sticking with it till I actually have every single bar of the song down, maybe I'll have it all down but then there will be an annoying run that I just need to work a bit more on, etc
But I would also like to get some really honest feedback, so I would know exactly which problems I should work on, hmm...
Anyways! Maybe you'll see me there someday soon!
Posted by: Kristofer Dahl Mar 21 2013, 12:52 PM
QUOTE (Qenzoz @ Mar 21 2013, 12:35 PM)
maybe I'll have it all down but then there will be an annoying run that I just need to work a bit more on, etc
That's the beauty with REC, it forces you to get the last details down (which can sometimes be the trickiest part).
I often find that attention to details is what set the pros apart.
So my previous recommendation applies to you as well - submit your first REC take and you will progress quicker!
Posted by: TreyDeschamp Mar 21 2013, 01:12 PM
I've thought this for a while!
Welcomed change for sure!
Posted by: HungryForHeaven Mar 21 2013, 01:42 PM
I also hope that this leads to a more consistent and reliable/fair grading of the takes. There are mainly two things that have annoyed me from time to time with the REC grading. One is that it is too easy to get the highest grade - if a take which is not perfect or very close to perfect receives a 10, then which grade should be given to a perfect take? Also, anyone grading the take should be (or become) somewhat familiar with the lesson, to avoid "I agree with what the other guys said" or "try to isolate the fast parts and practice them at a slower tempo" or other obvious standard replies.
Edit: After all, it's all about making progress and not compete with others about high grades. I'd say anyone benefits from making it more difficult to get a 10 - what is there to strive for beyond it?
Posted by: Headbanger Mar 21 2013, 01:53 PM
Whilst we are on the subject .....I must add my two penneth...
In the short time I have been here, I have noticed something about the difficulty grades of lessons....some of them are just not graded correctly. I think we are all aware of that. The reason I think we are all aware is that when a lesson is graded too low for its difficulty..example: a lesson is graded 2 and should really be 3 or even 4....nobody wants to spend their time doing' that perfect take'...if they don't get 'paid' properly ( we are humans and we know which side our bread is buttered)....therefore not many people seem to bother with REC takes on those ones...although they are great lessons and well worth learning.
On the other end of the scale the situation, in my opinion is reversed..example:. lessons that are easier but have a too high grade....everyone wants some of those easy points and understandably those ones get more takes.....
I also think there should be a site reward attached to the REC system to encourage people to take part....maybe a free month or two subscription.
EDIT: I forgot to say...that I think its a good idea that Kristofer Dahl wrote...Toughen up on marking....otherwise we will get no where!!!
Posted by: Jouve Mar 21 2013, 02:25 PM
Haha. Finally, I was too shy to ask for that
Posted by: mroberts70 Mar 21 2013, 02:31 PM
Anymore?
QUOTE (Gabriel Leopardi @ Mar 21 2013, 06:27 AM)
I'm not that nice guy any more...
Posted by: Darius Wave Mar 21 2013, 03:06 PM
Consider it done!
Posted by: Ekilo Mar 21 2013, 04:29 PM
I have not done a Rec yet but will be soon. I like the new rules and welcome them. I also encourage constructive feedback. Please never worry about hurting my feelings. Honest assesment is where it's at.
Posted by: Rated Htr Mar 21 2013, 04:35 PM
Never expected anything but this If I have the slightest error, the slightest mistake, I expect you TO RIP MY HEART OFF
Posted by: HungryForHeaven Mar 21 2013, 04:39 PM
QUOTE (Ekilo @ Mar 21 2013, 04:29 PM)
I have not done a Rec yet but will be soon. I like the new rules and welcome them. I also encourage constructive feedback. Please never worry about hurting my feelings. Honest assesment is where it's at.
Exactly! And this does not necessarily mean to be harsh, the GMC community makes an excellent example of places where people in general are knowledgeable yet humble, informative yet polite, etc. I don't see why this wouldn't prove itself to hold even with somewhat stricter grading rules.
Posted by: WeePee Mar 21 2013, 04:57 PM
H4H and Headbanger has good points !
I have also noticed this rec grading while ago
But I like this new update !!
Posted by: HungryForHeaven Mar 21 2013, 05:02 PM
Posted by: Headbanger Mar 21 2013, 05:36 PM
QUOTE (HungryForHeaven @ Mar 21 2013, 04:39 PM)
Exactly! And this does not necessarily mean to be harsh, the GMC community makes an excellent example of places where people in general are knowledgeable yet humble, informative yet polite, etc. I don't see why this wouldn't prove itself to hold even with somewhat stricter grading rules.
A beautiful statement old bean...full of decorum
Posted by: Dieterle Mar 21 2013, 05:54 PM
OHH i did know it somehow judgement day is near
so its time looking forward to a new record !
Posted by: Nava Mar 21 2013, 06:39 PM
Great
When u finally get a 10, u can jump up and scream like a crazy, knowing that u did a VERY good REC!
Posted by: Kristofer Dahl Mar 22 2013, 08:37 AM
QUOTE (HungryForHeaven @ Mar 21 2013, 01:42 PM)
I also hope that this leads to a more consistent and reliable/fair grading of the takes. There are mainly two things that have annoyed me from time to time with the REC grading. One is that it is too easy to get the highest grade - if a take which is not perfect or very close to perfect receives a 10, then which grade should be given to a perfect take? Also, anyone grading the take should be (or become) somewhat familiar with the lesson, to avoid "I agree with what the other guys said" or "try to isolate the fast parts and practice them at a slower tempo" or other obvious standard replies.
Edit: After all, it's all about making progress and not compete with others about high grades. I'd say anyone benefits from making it more difficult to get a 10 - what is there to strive for beyond it?
Agreed! Getting a 10 should be the ultimate reward (we can't turn the grades up to 11..!).
QUOTE (Headbanger @ Mar 21 2013, 01:53 PM)
In the short time I have been here, I have noticed something about the difficulty grades of lessons....some of them are just not graded correctly. I think we are all aware of that. The reason I think we are all aware is that when a lesson is graded too low for its difficulty..example: a lesson is graded 2 and should really be 3 or even 4....nobody wants to spend their time doing' that perfect take'...if they don't get 'paid' properly ( we are humans and we know which side our bread is buttered)....therefore not many people seem to bother with REC takes on those ones...although they are great lessons and well worth learning.
On the other end of the scale the situation, in my opinion is reversed..example:. lessons that are easier but have a too high grade....everyone wants some of those easy points and understandably those ones get more takes.....
If you don't agree with a particular lesson difficulty, feel free to point it out in the lesson feedback. (lesson difficulties aren't set in stone)
Posted by: Headbanger Mar 22 2013, 09:57 AM
QUOTE (Kristofer Dahl @ Mar 22 2013, 08:37 AM)
If you don't agree with a particular lesson difficulty, feel free to point it out in the lesson feedback. (lesson difficulties aren't set in stone)
The site is full of great lessons to learn regardless of the difficulty setting...but, if I were to decide to participate in the REC program, then I would select carefully....I am probably wrong anyway, what appears to be difficult can sometimes be easier than it looks and vice versa.....Its just very noticeable sometimes...of huge participation or none.
Posted by: Kristofer Dahl Mar 22 2013, 10:30 AM
QUOTE (Nava @ Mar 21 2013, 06:39 PM)
Great
When u finally get a 10, u can jump up and scream like a crazy, knowing that u did a VERY good REC!
Indeed! I think a grade 10 should mean that the student almost perfectly nails the instructors' timing, technique, tone and vibrato.
Posted by: Fran Mar 22 2013, 10:39 AM
Good call. Kepp those awesome REC takes coming, and pass or not, see your guitar skills ever rise!
Posted by: Darius Wave Mar 22 2013, 11:40 AM
QUOTE (HungryForHeaven @ Mar 21 2013, 01:42 PM)
I also hope that this leads to a more consistent and reliable/fair grading of the takes. There are mainly two things that have annoyed me from time to time with the REC grading. One is that it is too easy to get the highest grade - if a take which is not perfect or very close to perfect receives a 10, then which grade should be given to a perfect take? Also, anyone grading the take should be (or become) somewhat familiar with the lesson, to avoid "I agree with what the other guys said" or "try to isolate the fast parts and practice them at a slower tempo" or other obvious standard replies.
Edit: After all, it's all about making progress and not compete with others about high grades. I'd say anyone benefits from making it more difficult to get a 10 - what is there to strive for beyond it?
Indeed You're right - there was not enough headroom for people who do it really perfect. As for the second thing you've mentioned...Sometimes it would be hard to write something else while instructor who did his voting as a first wrote everything down and there is not too much to add. Third thing is many of students have same, common problems so it's obvious that some advice will repeat very often. For someone who learns to play guitar it could not be that obvious that he has some timing issues etc...even though he read that in a past few grading comments in REC section
Posted by: Kristofer Dahl Apr 8 2013, 10:44 AM
I am bumping this thread in case someone missed it!
Powered by Invision Power Board (http://www.invisionboard.com)
© Invision Power Services (http://www.invisionpower.com)