Printable Version of Topic

Click here to view this topic in its original format

GMC Forum _ Collaborations _ Fine Rock Melodies

Posted by: Nemanja Filipovic Aug 31 2008, 06:21 PM

Thanks every body for participating in this collab.This was a record for me when it comes to number of participants.
Ok here we go with comments.

Fine_Rock_Melodies_Final_Mix.mp3 ( 10.03MB ) : 380

Order of upload.

No.of participants:18

Superize
Smells
Vasilis
Tjcep
audiopal
kyldeee
siggum
Alex Lewis
Col Roberts
Bali
Bluesrock
leadbrake
Velvet Roger
Oxac
Lian
melodius
coffeman
Kaznie

And mine plus comments:

Vasilis:
Nice ideas here,expecialy liked the slide intro.I can see some good technique here,also I think you should haw a bit better tone control on faster and higher notes.All in all very good take man.

Smells:
Wow,perfect take Smells,good tone(witch is to me the most important thing)speed,and excellent frazing.Your solo ideas are great,and you can hear experience for shore.All in all,great take Smells.

Superize:
Well first part is good when it comes to idea,but I think that you need to practice a bit more frazes like that,so gain a bit more tone quality,also I missed the vibrato on the longer notes here.Vibrato is some thing to practice and it means a lot.Second part,where you come in with deeper notes,just before the end I like.It is a good take,am I shore that the more collabs you do you will become better,because I can hear that talent is there.

Tjchep:
Very nice take man,I like the effect you put on your guitar,blends very nice.Frsing is great,and the you really made a nice difference between the first and the second part,thaty kind of dynamic crescendo is very smart move on this backing track.All in all great take man.

Audiopal:
Oh,I really enjoy this take,nothing to add accept..Beautiful.Emotional,very smart solo and very well played,like the clean sound too.Thanks man,great take.

Kyldeee:
Very nice and simple take,you made a melody out of it,witch I like very much,expetialy the part just before the end..Good take man.

Siggum:
Great take man,really enjoy it.Melodies are great and the tone too.Scales are well played,and with scents.Thanks man,once again great take.

Alex Lewis:
Good take man,I like the long notes,maybe you should control them a bit better on the ends of the frazes.Nice tone in general,and I like the amount of drive you put for this take.

Col Roberts:
I like the second part with the intervals,first part needed to be with a bit more control,and with less drive in my opinion.Idea is great,very original all in all.

Bali:
Nice take man,once again I think that notes that need vibrato don't haw a much of him.Arpeggios are well played,and Idea for solo is good.Like the jump on the beginning too .Thanks man,good Take.

Bluesrock:
I really like the beginning,and I think you should made a bit more of the second part,not in the way you played,but in melodic way.You did the melodic crescendo,but IMO,you should go to octave higher.I certainly feel progress in you playing.
Thanks man.

Leadbrake:
Very original take man,I wish you uploaded one with backing and one without,bout are with,but I manage some thing,and every thing works out great.Very good idea,and I really like your tone,frazing is great,control too.Great take man.Thanks.

Velvet Roger:
Nice and original take man,especially the second part.You should maby work on your tone and drive amount.But except that take is very good.
Thanks man.

Lain:
Amazing man.Just showes how good guitarist you are,if you can play some thing out of the music you love and it steal sound great and innovate.Thanks man,great take.

Oxac:
On,this sounds so great man.
Melodies are great and the way you played too.Tone is a killer one.All in all great take man.

Melodius:
Great warm take man,second part is a killer one.Very smart.I really liked the take man,nothing to add.Thanks.

Coffeman:
Nice take man,I would go with less drive here,but steal sounds very good.Idea is good and frazing too.Very well played.Thanks.

KAznie:
You are improving my friend.Very good take,and you played it ok.I dont like your tone,but frazing is ok.
Good take Kaznie.Thanks.

The order is random,and it does not haw any special meaning.I rally did my best to help with comments as much that I know and I can.
I think that you all played great,and whats more important you improved from the last one,and from all of the collabs you did here at GMC.
Thanks guys.

Posted by: superize Aug 31 2008, 06:37 PM

Great takes from everybody and thanks for the comment Nemanja

Posted by: Bali Aug 31 2008, 06:45 PM

Such a cool collab!!

Thanks everybody!!

Posted by: Siggum Aug 31 2008, 06:53 PM

Cool collab Nemanja, and thanks for the comments

Posted by: Oxac Aug 31 2008, 07:34 PM

Thanks for a great collab and a very nice compliment You could work a little on your spelling though, but it's not really annoying.

-Edit- I really had a great time doing this!

Posted by: audiopaal Aug 31 2008, 07:45 PM

Thanks for the comments Nemanja
Very nice work and a great Collab!!!

Posted by: Tjchep Aug 31 2008, 07:52 PM

Great collab guys, enjoyed everyones take.

Posted by: kaznie_NL Aug 31 2008, 07:59 PM

Thnx Nemanja! I'm happy with my comment

Posted by: skennington Aug 31 2008, 09:26 PM

Wow, what a great collab to have missed.. A few days late and a dollar short I enjoyed all of you guys. Guess I may as well upload my take...Tho no comparison, I still had fun with it.

Great backing Nemanja and great takes everyone.

Nemanja_Sk.mp3 ( 492.97K ) : 202

Posted by: Velvet Roger Aug 31 2008, 10:22 PM

Thanks for the mixing and comments Nemanja

Posted by: Lian Gerbino Aug 31 2008, 10:51 PM

awesome work! really great takes guys!
mix is really cool! thanks for the comment btw!

Posted by: kyldeee Sep 1 2008, 12:49 PM

Awesome collab indeed
Thanks for the comments Nemanja

Posted by: Bluesrock Sep 1 2008, 07:25 PM

Thanks for the compliment and colab Nemanja, can't wait for the next one

Posted by: Col Roberts Sep 2 2008, 06:47 AM

Thanks for a great collab Nemanja. Well done everyone.

Posted by: leedbreak Sep 3 2008, 01:43 AM

Lots of fun, sorry about the upload mistake, forgot to turn the backing off for the second render, LOL

Should have PMed me

Great Collab,

Thanks

Posted by: Juan M. Valero Sep 3 2008, 08:56 AM

hey is a cool collab !!!! congratulations to all members here and congrats to Nemanja, mate, you did a great work

Posted by: coffeeman Sep 3 2008, 03:52 PM

Great collab Nemanja, thanks for the comments and nice takes from everyone.

Posted by: Ivan Milenkovic Sep 4 2008, 03:42 PM

Aaah, such a fine collab, great job guys

Posted by: Bogdan Radovic Sep 5 2008, 05:08 PM

Excellent collab , great job guys , and cool mix Nemanja !

Posted by: Pedja Simovic Sep 18 2008, 02:10 AM

I love the backing and some very cool solos - this is awesome everyone!