I am a total and utter Red Dwarf fan ... (In fact I AM Lister)
My wife is baffled that I can watch a 3 second clip of any show and give her the name, series and synopsis
Best red dwarf ever was Back to Reality IMO, Season V was the classic series.
Also love doctor who - for me the classic period was Jon Pertwee/Tom Baker (I was too young for the first 2 doctors).
I also love the new series, I think they have done a great job of reinventing it - the new Daleks scare me as much now as the old ones did when I was 5 years old!
Here was are in total agreement on this. They all were good. Including Kryten. The guy that played Rimmer, he is good. I mean he can play Ace Rimmer, and Rimmer, totally different characters, and do it well. Good actor. Red Dwarf is so good. I am thinking that one day America is going to discover that series. A lot of people like it, but some have never heard of it. It is a classic.
Baker will always be my favorite Who, but like them all. The new guy is good. Liked the one that lasted only a year also.
edit: hard to say what my favorite is of Red Dwarf, so many good ones. But the one where Lister missed Rimmer, and then had that Dream where he kissed him, and woke up screaming. Then that ride that Kryten arranged where they played that Rimmer song, that is up there among my favorites for sure.
I have watched them all multi times, more than I care to admit.