Learning Tone Master Posts: 2.324
Joined: 12-July 13
From: Bucharest, Romania
QUOTE (MisterM @ Aug 12 2019, 08:42 AM)
Hi
my thumb does not have the necessary amplitude but progress will come from working. However, the small progress gives me the feeling that it’s a little easier to play
Judging after the fact that have passed only few days from your last post, I can say that you definitely made a big improvement. Your thumb looks better because you eliminated that irregular movement. This is an awesome thing. Also you achieved a relaxing in playing and I like this very much.
Now the main problem that does not let you to achieve this thumb joint movement in a correct way, still remains your wrist. In your video you use the wrist for the movement and this should not happen. As Todd showed you in his video, his wrist stay blocked and only the thumb do the job.
Try to work on this area. Force your wrist to not make any move. Probably you will need to make a little more visible the stretch and bend movement of your thumb. At this moment you minimized this thumb movement but not because of the speed, because of your wrist which still make the motion.
One more thing. I want to assure myself that I pointed everything to not let any misunderstanding to occur.
In Vivaldi Winter Arpeggios lesson, Cosmin don't use the thumb movement. So, if you compare your take with original take made by Cosmin, keep in mind that your wrist should not make the same motion as in the Cosmin's take. You work at a different technique which can be used in many situations including the lesson made by Cosmin. If I remember well, instructors mentioned about the thumb joint movement when you posted in REC "Triplet Etude". But there Piotr use the thumb movement and his wrist and pinky finger stay in the same place entire lesson. I wanted to mention this to be sure that you not take as reference how Cosmin move the wrist.