Hey there fellow GMCers
Today I've decided to make a "versus" competition between two cleaning agents that I've been using for quite some time.Of course this is only my humble opinion and I wont try to persuade you which product to buy.I'll just try to weight the pros and cons of each kit and hope that you find this review helpful.
The agents I'll compare are two of the most known and most expensive in the market right now. I'm talking about the DUNLOP MAINTENANCE KIT and the GIBSON AIGG-RK1.According to Thomman ...

http://www.thomann.de/gr/dunlop_maintenance_kit.htm

http://www.thomann.de/gr/gibson_giggrk1.htm

DUNLOP MAINTENANCE KIT


The Dunlop maintenance kit consists of 5 accessories
Formula 65 Polish, Bodygloss 65 Cream of Carnauba Wax, Ultraglide 65 String Saver, Fingerboard 01 Cleaner/Prep, Fingerboard 02 Conditioner, and 2 cotton polish cloths

Formula 65 Polish and cleaner
A really great cleaner. I used it on my epiphone and completely took away signs of fingerprints and sweat.But I found it a bit hard to scratch tiny details from the headstock
RATE: 4/6

Body gloss 65 Cream of Carnauba Wax
Now this will make the body shine like a mirror.I was surprised to see my old guitars look like new
RATE:5/6

Ultraglide 65 String Saver
This one does the same job as the Fast fret. When you apply it to the strings it makes them "glide" and and extends their "string" life
RATE:5/6

Fingerboard 01 Cleaner/Prep
Now this cleaning agent is truly amazing and I think all guitarists must own one. It comes in spray form making the removal of grime fast and easy. The pack includes 2 cloths with one harsh surface,specially designed for removing the dirt.I SWEAR,after I sprayed for the first time I could see the grain had turned to liquid clay and started dripping down the neck.Pretty powerful stuff
RATE:6/6

Fingerboard 02 Conditioner
After Fingerboard 01 Cleaner/Prep the 02 conditioner is applied, protects and replenishes the wood of the fingerboard.Pretty cool
RATE:6/6

OVERALL 6/6
VALUE: 23,60 euro in thomman

GIBSON AIGG-RK1


The Gibson set comes with three cleaning agents. Restorative finish cream, Fretboard- and Metalcleaner (with Brush, Polish and Polish-Cloth)

Restorative finish cream
Great, amazing, fantastic cleaner. Especially for Vintage instruments.Just pour some on the guitar body and with the cloth that is inside the kit with wax-on wax-off movements it restores the original glamor and shining of the instrument. You should check it in sunlight and you'll understand. Also I had no trouble removing small details.
RATE:6/6

Fretboard Cleaner
This one is actually pretty lame.It is the classic lemon-oil cleaner that we love to hate. It needs stable hand or else small accidents can happen very easily.Your hand will TRULY hurt after scrubbing the fingerboard fret by fret.Also you might wanna try something else for cleaning than the original gibson yellow cloth(its a shame to destroy it).Another thing.All 3 cleaners heads open and close like a screw. My Fretboard cleaner also has a small leak.I examined the botle to see if I can find a hole, but no luck.So I'm guessing that it might be the heads fault.
RATE:2/6

Metalcleaner
Metalcleaner is pretty cool for applying to the metallic parts(keys,screws,pick ups covers etc),and that's where the small brush comes in handy.
RATE:5/6

OVERALL 5/6
VALUE: 14,40 euro in thomman

PROS AND CONS
1
DUNLOP
+ All vials are in spray form and designed in a way that they wont spilled or make a mess of your area
GiBSON
- The complete opposite.The screw heads are a bit risky and a firm hand and workbench is required

2
DUNLOP
+ The cloth that comes along is amazing and just by wrapping it around your fingertip it can do wonders
GIBSON
- GIBSON comes with two cleaning cloths.The one is pretty useless and they do tend to gather a lot of dirt.

3
GIBSON
+ Has a metalcleaner
DUNLOP
-Has no metalcleaner

So finally I guess if you ask me which one the best I must say that I find the Dunlop much more friendly and easy but in the other hand the GIBSON is also nice because of the metalcleaner, the great restorative finish cream and the brush. So it might be best if you had both or just select some of the vials that you need more.
Also if someone of you uses different cleaning agents please let me know. I'm interested about the music man care set and some Planet waves products
Anyway I hope you found the review useful and please forgive my terrible English
Cheers

Very interesting comparison.

I never thought of using anything but a soft fabric to clean my guitars , but I shall give this a try

Thanks for the review ! I don't actually use anything but fast fret for strings..I'm gonna get this dunlop set though!

Thanks for the comparison,

I use the fretboard cleaner and the conditioner for some time now, and it works flawless (not to be used on maple necks btw ). Fast fret I use as well. Will check out the metalcleaner and the body polisher stuff as well.

Nice comparison man. I've been using the dunlop kit for about 3-4 years now and it worked perfect for me. I prolly should give a try to Gibson.

Interesting test, good one!!